J.C. Sipe Jewelers

Do you need help? Please call us at (317) 848-0215.

(317) 848-0215 Hours & Directions

Testimonials

Write Your Own

Schedule Appointment

About 18 years ago I received a gorgeous engagement ring and wedding band from J C Sipe. I loved it daily, but was not a good steward of maintaining it. Recently, I returned to the jewelers for a “correction.” I live 60+ miles away but I knew I wanted to ... go to the right people for the right job. Sam, the owner is not just a jeweler, but a teacher. I left this place not only with a glorious ring set but also a deeper understanding of the best way to honor the purchase made 18 years ago. There are many options for jewelers. The corporate, professional and personal values of JC Sipe give this company the competitive edge. Leslie A. Bassett Nashville, IN Read More
  • - Leslie Bassett
I recently purchased a custom designed engagement ring from JC Sipe. Sam, Laura and Garnet were an absolute pleasure to work. My girlfriend (now fiancé 😉) and I were clueless walking in but Sam (owner) was so helpful and was willing to spend quality time with us from the get ... go. My experience was far beyond expectations and here’s some reasons why: -Sam explained engagement ring types, diamonds, pricing to the level that I was willing to go. I have a lot of questions and curiosities and he was thorough with me. -SAM RESPECTED MY BUDGET. I was always comfortable with Sam and the team. I visited another jewelry store and that was not the culture. -We created a custom ring. Having that option was ideal but could have been intimidating. Sam helped narrow in our taste so I wasn’t overwhelmed with too many decision. It was a great balance. The custom design was perfect. -Garnet crafted the ring in house which was so cool to see the evolution of a drawing to the finished, polished ring. He is so skilled! I highly recommend working with JC Sipe. Read More
  • - Jake B
From education, purchase, service and help after buying an engagement ring the JC Sipe team is awesome! Highly recommend!
  • - Isaiah Douglass
My family has used JC Sipe for years and we have always been very impressed. Their customer service is fantastic and they are always willing to help you get exactly what you want. I also appreciate that they have a wide price range so you can find something no matter ... what your budget is. Read More
  • - Rhiannon Miller
Sipe Jewlers are high quality jewelers. Their jewelry is made with care, taste and an eye for beauty. I highly recommend them.
  • - Thomas G. Fisher
After 25 years of marriage I went back to Sam and Laura for an anniversary ring because I knew I could trust them. I bought Amy's engagement ring and wedding band from them on the recommendation of my father-in-law, who was a long-time customer. He's given me a lot of ... lot of good advice over the years but this recommendation has stood the test of time. We now live in Seattle, WA. So the fact that the entire transaction was done online and through phone calls with Sam should be a testament to how much I trust their integrity and good taste. Read More
  • - David and Amy Mack
Sam and Laura Sipe made my engagement ring shopping experience the most fun, painless, and smooth process I could ever imagine. Walking in describing what I want and getting not only what I wanted but all the extra detail to really make it go over the top was incredible. The ... amount of effort and interest they showed towards me and my plans were beyond my expectations. To be able to go in with a mental picture of what I wanted but not have much knowledge of rings and the result be perfect, shows the class and expertise J.C Sipe Jewelers have. Having a plan for yourself but an open mind when talking to Sam is my suggestion on finding the perfect ring or jewelry piece for your significant other. Sipes are our jewelers for years to come because of the first impression and experience I got shopping for an engagement ring. Read More
  • - Nate holm
Sam Sipe has been in business for years. He is an old school, true & honest Jeweler! Don't go to the people that run radio and tv commercials over and over. Sam does not need commercials. He has word of mouth and years of great experiences. Sam is truly a ... very professional jeweler. Read More
  • - John M.
Sam Sipe runs a great jewelry shop! I picked a beautiful set of earrings for my girlfriend here. She loved them. Thank you Sam! Read More
  • - Grant K.
My wife and I have enjoyed working with Sam and Laura Sipe for many years now. I say work "with" because they have always done an excellent job of listening, educating and guiding us towards the perfect purchase. Whether it's professional help designing the perfect ring, picking out a great ... great pair of earrings or a beautiful necklace or even just getting a repair done to existing jewelry we have never been disappointed. Honesty is something that is very important to us, especially when we are spending our hard earned dollars. Sam and Laura have earned our trust over the years by telling us the truth. If an existing piece isn't worth the repair fee, they have let us know. If we made a bad choice elsewhere buying some inferior gem they have gently let us down but gave us the straight story. Their store is a real gem. Great location on E. 96th just west of Keystone, it's open layout, clean as a whistle, great lighting and if you know where the candy dish is you are already ahead of the game. Any mention of Sipe Jewelers wouldn't be complete without a compliment to Garnett, their master craftsman. He is just amazing! We have never been happier with anyone's work or felt more cared for. He really is a pro! Treat yourself to a real professional jeweler and visit them today to check out some amazing pieces. I guarantee you'll agree with me. They are one of the best in town! Read More
  • - George R.
Sam and Laura Sipe are top notch jewelry professionals in my opinion. I've had custom work designed, new pieces purchased and rework done on my existing jewelry. In every case, I was 100% satisfied. The friendly atmosphere, consultative selling and a true respect for my wishes and opinions really sets ... these folks apart from the rest of the crowd. I'm please to recommend them for evaluations, repairs, new pieces and custom work. It's hard to find someone you believe in and trust in this business but Sam and Laura have earned mine over the years. These folks are great and really make you wonder about all the other "discount" and "mall" jewelers that are hawking their wares. I highly recommend you visit and see for yourself. Read More
  • - Kim G.
My now-fiancé and I worked with Sam to make the perfect engagement ring — he was extremely helpful, especially considering I had some unusual requests. He absolutely went the extra mile. He spent a lot of time educating us on the options, the process, what to consider, etc. I can't ... more highly of the service and product I received. I'm definitely a customer for life! Read More
  • - J.T.


Please feel free to contact us.

We have jewelry professionals ready to help.

Contact Us Appointment

J.C. Sipe Jewelers